Dairy-Free Homemade Butterscotch Baking Chips

Dairy-Free Homemade Butterscotch Baking Chips

For baking or simply snacking, these homemade butterscotch baking chips solve the problem faced by those of us who are dairy-free in addition to being gluten free.
Make a batch (or two!) of these to use in all your favorite recipes calling for butterscotch morsels.

5.0 from 1 reviews
Dairy-Free Homemade Butterscotch Baking Chips
Recipe type: Dessert
  • 1 cup brown sugar, firmly packed
  • ¼ cup dairy-free butter substitute (like Earth Balance buttery spread; I use the soy-free variety.)
  • 2 Tablespoons dairy-free milk (Any plant-based milk will work; I use coconut milk.)
  • ½ teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  1. Before you begin, line a cookie sheet with parchment paper or wax paper.
  2. Combine all ingredients except vanilla.
  3. Cook over medium heat until mixture comes to a boil.
  4. Boil 2 minutes without stirring.
  5. Remove from heat, add vanilla and stir.
  6. Pour mixture onto prepared parchment-lined pan.
  7. Allow mixture to cool to room temperature until it hardens.
  8. Cut into chunks.
  9. Store in glass jar, tightly sealed.


  • These chips make the perfect addition to my Gluten Free Magic 7-Layer Bars!
Gluten Free Gigi

Sign up to get all my FREE RECIPES and Smart Nutrition Backed by Science wellness and nutrition ARTICLES!

Get YOUR copy of The Gluten-Free Solution: Your Ultimate Guide to Positive Gluten-Free Living today!

It’s also available for Kindle!

As someone with celiac disease and multiple food allergies, Gigi understands how food can harm or heal. Fully restoring her own health with diet alone after a 25-year health struggle, Gigi now uses her own experiences and the skills she gained as a former neuroscience researcher to share practical, easy-to-understand strategies, science-backed nutrition information, immediately useful tips and recipes to make gluten-free living liberating and positive for everyone!
  • sr

    I just used a different internet recipe (I didn’t mind using organic butter, so I used the coconut oil / butter / brown sugar recipe) and I had problems with both graininess and separation. I make toffee fairly regularly and so I am used to higher-temp sugar recipes, but I am struggling with the whole brown-sugar-stays-grainy thing. Commenters contradict themselves… you have to stir less. (No, more!) You have to boil longer (no, less!) Hotter! Too hot! … I am hesitant to waste more brown sugar and butter and coconut oil (7 bucks a jar! Yeep!) until I am confident about what to vary. Even using your recipe, I feel as if the not-dissolving thing could happen. Ideas?? Also I just read another recipe (which used shortening) where commenters complained the homemade chips melt so entirely that there’s no “chip” left in the cookie. Any ideas appreciated.

    • http://www.glutenfreegigi.com Gluten Free Gigi

      The brown sugar issue may be getting the mixture too hot too fast. Slow is the key with melting granulated/brown sugar.

      I’m not sure about “commenters’, I’m guessing you mean from other sites or where you got a recipe you tried?

      I do not recommend coconut oil for this recipe. If you have another recipe where it is used/called for, go for it, but I do not suggest using it here due to its properties. You will surely not have any “chip” or “chunk” if you do.

      Note: my recipe does not call for coconut oil.

      I do not use/recommend shortening.

      My suggestion: either use a recipe and follow it specifically/precisely, or query the author/recipe creator of the site to which you keep referring.

  • betty hatfield

    I made these the other day. After I broke the butterscotch into pieces, I dipped them into melted chocolate, and sprinkled a little sea salt on top. They were sooo good.

    • http://www.glutenfreegigi.com Gluten Free Gigi

      Hi, Betty.

      You are a genius!! I love this idea and am so happy you shared it here with everyone! :)

      Thank you!


  • farrah haley

    can you use butter?

    • http://www.glutenfreegigi.com Gluten Free Gigi

      Hi, Farrah.

      Never dried (I can’t use dairy); however, I’d say it is likely going to work.

      A little kitchen experiment might be in order! ;)

      Let me know if you try it and how it turns out, others would probably like to know.


  • Pingback: Gluten Free Allergen-Free Holiday Pantry Staples | Start Gluten Free()

  • Jane Cunningham

    Can you use Sucanat instead of brown sugar? My son has a sensitivity to brown sugar.

    • glutenfreegigi

      Sounds like you’ve got yourself a great experiment in the making, Jane! Best luck and let us know how it turns out if you give it a try! xo